MaxDrei commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
....and, for my part, I don't understand why you keep harping on about the difference in effect, between the left hand and the right hand of an old body. We already know everything about the structural...
View Articlesimple questions commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of...
My apologies MaxDrei. I thought you were familiar with the basic historical context of the US law involved in this issue. My mistake.
View ArticleIf It's Good Enough For MM, It Should Be Good Enough For You commented on...
Yes, please hang your hat instead on the mindless rantings of MM and his various sxckpuppets. Pay no heed to those in the judiciary who have earned respect through their years of ardent service and are...
View ArticleIANAE commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
the effect of the isolated molecule has a drasticly difference in kind?It's not different in kind. Even in the extreme (Sanofi) case where you basically have dextro-medicine mixed with levo-poison, the...
View ArticleIANAE commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
Why then should you get a patent for an isolated left hand, as such, per se, even before it does anything?You shouldn't, of course. But you should get a patent to an isolated right hand, because an...
View ArticleGeorge Graff commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of...
It is not "mere discovery" to apply a process g to transform it into somethin useful that does not exist in nature.
View ArticleKeep Your Eye On The Ball commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings...
Thanks G. Nobody is arguing that, but we will keep it in mind if it comes up.
View ArticleNed Heller commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis...
Max, I presume that the chemical structure of the the L or the R enantiomers was known or obvious over the race mixture. But even so, no one knew how to separate the two from the mixture.I think that...
View ArticleBasic Logic commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis...
"It's not different in kind."I would disagree. It certainly is of a greater difference than of in degree, and it certainly is not the same.Basic set theory leaves little choice but different in kind.
View ArticleMaxDrei commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
I excuse you. No problem. Don't worry about it.
View ArticleMM commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v. Mulford'
Ned I presume that the chemical structure of the the L or the R enantiomers was known or obvious over the race mixture. But even so, no one knew how to separate the two from the mixture.What case are...
View ArticleMM commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v. Mulford'
Pay no heed to those in the judiciary who have earned respect through their years of ardent service and are otherwise recognized as experts in law.9-0, suckie.9-0.I wish I could make the stinging...
View ArticleMM commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v. Mulford'
Pay no heed to those in the judiciary who have earned respect through their years of ardent service and are otherwise recognized as experts in law.Hey, Harkness: still waiting for an answer, bro'.
View Articleanislandofreason commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of...
The string claimed in the Myriad patent has not been transformed from the string as it occurs in nature. Nature defines its borders, not man. Nothing has been transformed in the case of Myriad's...
View ArticleNed Heller commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis...
The UK Supreme Court case Max is referencing.
View Articleanislandofreason commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of...
There's an easy way to tell the difference between nature and everything else: does its form depend upon man's design and intention, or would it exist as it does regardless of man's design and...
View ArticleIANAE commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
its existence is presupposed by the standard model of particle physics. No more than the existence of the steam engine is "presupposed" by the standard model of thermodynamics.If the Higgs were just...
View ArticleNed Heller commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis...
An Island,1) the Constitution grants congress the power to protect discoveries; and2) Congress, beginning in 1790, as reenacted in every update thereafter, authorized patents on discoveries. In 1793,...
View ArticleIANAE commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis v....
1) the Constitution grants congress the power to protect discoveries;To secure the right to "Inventors". What do you suppose they meant by "Discoveries", if they only conferred rights to "Inventors"?...
View ArticleNed Heller commented on 'Guest Post: Myriad Misunderstandings of Parke-Davis...
Discoveries of ...compositions of matter is what has been the law since 1793.Sent from iPhone
View Article
